Tuesday 13 May 2014

#11 (Pseudo)Freedom of Press in India

It's been a very long time since I posted my last article. Recently the world observed 3rd May as "World press freedom day". I came to know about this when my sister who is a journalism student post about it on facebook. There were few comments of her friends who criticized the press. This left me with no choice but to write on this topic. Journalism is considered the biggest ideological weapon and its history is long. Newspapers have always been the primary medium of journalists since 1600, with magazines came in the 18th century, radio and television in the 20th, and the Internet in the 21st century.

History stores the extensive role played by journalism not in India but in the entire World. The Independence movement of various countries, the revolutions around the globe and social activism are helped by journalism to people to reach the destination. The freedom of this profession always tried to suppressed by the monarchist, dictators, and ruling regimes. Every ruler tries to take remote in their hands to control it. But press is effective only when it is free to express. It is well said by the Nobel Prize winner journalist Albert Camus that "A free press can, of course, be good or bad, but, most certainly without freedom, the press will never be anything but bad".  According to press freedom index India comes in the category of countries where press is in difficult situation. India ranks 140th position in terms of freedom of press. It's not a good indication in a vibrant democracy like us where media is considered so called "Fourth Pillar of democracy". Journalism is a great source of information and empowers the people if it is free from any censorship. But question is: Is it free in our country?

The Constitution of India provides the right to freedom. The right to freedom in guarantees the Freedom of speech and expression. But recently Doordarshan had edited out portions from Modi's interview created a massive controversy. It's clearly seems that National news broadcaster is still not acquired complete autonomy from MIB (Ministry of Information and Broadcasting). Yes Indian constitution enables the legislature to impose certain restrictions on free speech under some heads likes security of the country, public order and sovereignty and integrity of India etc, but to censor media for playing politics is not good for healthy democracy. When few months ago Penguin India withdrawn all copies of Wendy Doniger’s The Hindus: An Alternative History from the Indian market erupted same controversy in media world over the freedom of speech. In this matter not only the government is but the people of this country equally responsible. We are actually losing an opportunity to enjoy this right. We can easily lose our mental state by just listening to other's view especially when the matter of discussion centered to religion. Democracy allows people to express their views and thoughts. Recently in general elections the picture seems opposite. Today's Netas are not cool minded as they are supposed to and like what kind of Netas born earlier. The increment in the personal attack also had broken many records in this poll season. As long as our representatives do not show signs of improvement until people can not get changed.

This could be one side of the paper but on another side media is not completely clean. Media in country did a lot to uphold the voice of people but in a decade after the technology changed the scenario it's very important for press to raise the standards through a code of conduct. There are so many news mediums are available in country but sometimes we see the content shown by some TV news channels are not as much as important or needless. In a race to raise the TRP, media is hurting their image. This should be stop and here Press council of India can play an important role. It would be better for media and the viewer if the media regulates themselves and understood the nature of content required. Many a times we saw the competition to report the event or any big happening by reporters rules out the moral values. I'm also against the entry polls surveys conducted by the news houses before the election. They are free to do that but it definitely influences the mind of voters. This distraction of mind of voters are harmful for democracy. In this election paid news are big point of controversy and this is a new threat which deepens their roots strong. In a recent judgment The Supreme Court said that "the Election Commission is empowered to probe into the allegations of paid news if the expenses for the same are not being reflected in the election return filed by the candidate". This shows that the paid news is a big problem and commendable steps should be taken to stop this. Media must not bias to anyone but they must show what is right because media is doing most important service of educating people.

Society is influenced by media in so many ways. It has played significant role in strengthening the society. Media is considered as mirror of the modern society. The purpose of the media is to inform people about current new affairs and to tell about the latest gossip and fashion and many more. Here I believe there are need to change content pattern in the media especially in print media. If we compare our newspapers with the western counterparts, we find we have more reports on politics than science and technology. The double way communication with the viewers and readers are also need of modern time. That's why social media is playing a huge role in today's world. No doubt, overall Indian press is doing exceptionally well but some issues are yet to tackle immediately to increase the credibility and to improve image of Indian media among people and the world. Media is greatly done in this 16th Loksabha election which result the highest voter turnout in Indian polling history. This is a good sign that our media and democracy are maturing. Important issues during the campaign included rising prices, corruption, economy and security, infrastructure such as roads, electricity and water were raised by media which helped voters to vote smartly. Indian democracy is on its way towards maturity and the is great responsibility on shoulders of media to play its critical role to educate people because history have this quote said by great journalist Joseph Pulitzer that "Republic and its press will rise or fall together".

- Prateek Dixit